Indisputable Eight

What you will apprehend is an acknowledgment to the accusation of anyone nicknamed Just Study who I met in Muxlim.com. He doubted that nubuwwah or predictions about the attendance of Muhammad PBUH. abide in antecedent scriptures.

Book 5 of Jewish books at already is the Christian Old Testament, the Book of Deuteronomy, in affiliate 18, ballad 18 independent the chat of God to Moses as as follows:
"A astrologer will aloft by Me for them from a part of their own brothers, like unto thee: I will put my words in his mouth, and he would acquaint them aggregate I command him."


You can see there is a byword which I accent above. Although its anatomy is short, instead of that simple byword had built-in differences, conflicts, and disputes a part of the three followers of all-powerful religions: Jews, Christians, and Muslims.


Let's appraise one by one. How do these three humans of altered angle about the endure astrologer who is "Moses alike".


Jews accede that a messiah will appear endure of their class, their race: Jewish. This appearance is actual and in accordance with the chat of God. But if it came to Jesus (Isa), still the Jews abjure that Jesus was the messiah endure the accessible it. According to Jewish, could not be a astrologer built-in from the chic of accustomed people, while Moses was a brood of the abundant kings of the Jews: Sulayman and his father, David a.s. Moreover, the Jews anticipation Jesus was built-in of the affair because it is not accepted who her biological father. This is a abandoned aspersion in Christians and Muslims' point of viev.


Jews (and Christians) aswell alone the prophethood of Muhammad PBUH. because he was of Arab descent, not Jewish. And they know, the Astrologer Muhammad PBUH. are birth of Ishmael a.s. the adulterated Ibrahim a.s: ancestor of Jew's clans.

                                                         Ibhrahim a.s.

                                                           /        \

                                                          /          \

                                                 Ismail a.s.     Ishak a.s.

                                                 (elder)         (youngest)

                                                  /                          \

                                                 /                             \

                                             Arab                       Jews  

God even echo the advice on the "from a part of their own relatives" in the Qur'an (At-Tawba:128).
لقد جآءڪم رسول من أنفسڪم
Now hath appear unto you an agent from amidst yourselves,


Jews altercate that the botheration is Mom of Ismail (Hajar) was the additional wife of Abraham and in fact is a slave. Until now, the Jews still attending advanced to the accession of the promised messiah last.


Christians sees that being referred to in branch Book of Deuteronomy it is Jesus of Nazareth. The reason: Moses was a Jew, Jesus, too. Moses, a messiah, Jesus, too. That's it.


Muslims, the Quran holds that there are at atomic three things that announce that the Astrologer Isa not the aforementioned as the astrologer Moses. Here's the arguments.

• Christians agrees that Jesus was aswell God, while Moses was a astrologer by his people, not God;
• Christians accede that Jesus died to absolve for the sins of men, while Moses did not die for it;
• Christians accept Jesus anytime went to hell for three canicule while Moses did not accomplish the trip.

Furthermore, Muslims filed eight arguments that appearance similarities amid Moses and Muhammad.

• Moses had a ancestor and mother. Muhammad, too. While he alone had a mother;
• Moses and Muhammad were built-in commonly and naturally, that is through the concrete bond amid a man and woman, while Jesus was created by a appropriate miracle;
• Moses and Muhammad affiliated and accept children, while Jesus remained a available throughout his life;
• Moses and Muhammad accustomed as Prophets by their humans in their lives. While Jesus was alone by his humans and had even denied by the acceptance themselves;
• Moses and Muhammad were prophets as able-bodied as the baron (in the faculty accustomed ascendancy in free and chief the law for his people), while he accepted he was not baron for this world;
• Moses and Muhammad brought new laws and rules for his people, while he acknowledges that his attendance is to accomplish the law of Moses (Torah);
• Moses and Muhammad died in a accustomed death, while according to Christian teachings, Jesus was actively murdered on the cross;
• Moses and Muhammad lay active in the earth, while according to Christian teaching, Jesus was comatose in heaven.

Thus the description of the 8th accurate altercation (the Islamic version) about the apocalypse of Muhammad's presence. as the messiah or the endure prophet. Look, those eight arguments all are just based on a ballad of scripture that is accustomed and endemic by Jews and Christians.

Allah Knows Best.

{A re-presentation of The Choice: Islam and Christianity by Ahmed Hoosen Deedat.}

Adam Troy Effendy
By Pusaka Madinah
Published: 2010-10-31T19:52:00+07:00
Indisputable Eight
5 411 reviews